I visited on a bad day. The printer was down, so all the phoned in orders (includig mine) was not prepared. There was a line from the order counter to the door and chaos behind the counter. Points to the management team for giving me a coupon for a free sandwich - stuff happens and they did their best to deal with a difficult situation.
My two-rating is more a function of the disappointing Philly Cheesesteak sub, which should have been in Jersey Mike's wheelhouse. The nondescript bread was almost devoid of any flavor. The cheese sauce was as sloppy as expected, but the was no napkins in the bag to deal with the mess. In addition, the sautéed onions had an off taste. To their credit, the kitchen was extremely generous with the portioning of the meat. With dozens of sandwiches places in town, I didn't find any compelling reason to ever return to Jersey Mike's.
Quite excellent. I had the #13 sub, Mike's way. The Italian bread was fresh, crusty on the outside and soft on the inside. The meats were sliced thin. I'd say they're a step above Cousin's (for the Italian Special), and a step just below Fraboni's. The Middleton crew was spectacular. They cared about how my sandwich tasted. I hope we get one on the East Side soon.
Hands down fresh cut meat right there in front of you makes all he difference, long time fan of some of the other chains but when mikes opened the rest just couldn’t compare with the quality of meat and freshness! Will always recommend people to come here and be Staff is great!
Subs were good and I liked their humorous attitude and friendliness. Thought $22 for two subs, drinks, and chips was outrageous but all in all good food.
The best part about the Jersey Mike's Subs is that they slice the meat thinly as you order. There's nothing sitting around waiting for you. The bread is excellent as well. My son requests to go here often and gets the Super Sub. The hot Subs look excellent, but we haven't tried them yet.
Jersey Mike S Subs is a US Restaurant based in Middleton, Wisconsin. Jersey Mike S Subs is located at 1601 Deming Way, Middleton, WI 53562, USA.
Please contact with Jersey Mike S Subs using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Jersey Mike S Subs opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.
Find Restaurant in Middleton